Page 1 of 1

Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 5:19 pm
by Soph K
do you think there should be a topic for recaps (with no discussion except if there's a mistake in one of the recaps)? debate...

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 5:31 pm
by Joseph Krol
Soph K wrote:do you think there should be a topic for recaps? debate...
It would be a bit impractical having all recaps in a single topic, as it would take ages to find any one recap.

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 5:38 pm
by Charlie Reams
Soph K wrote:do you think there should be a topic for recaps? debate...
Stop using allcaps in your topic titles please.

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 5:40 pm
by Soph K
Charlie Reams wrote:
Soph K wrote:do you think there should be a topic for recaps? debate...
Stop using allcaps in your topic titles please.
Edited.

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 6:30 pm
by Gevin Chapwell
I think it would be too annoying. I find it a bit awkward finding recaps in tournmaments where they are all lumped in together.

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 7:04 pm
by Ryan Taylor
Gavin Chipper wrote:I think it would be too annoying. I find it a bit awkward finding recaps in tournmaments where they are all lumped in together.
Yep like the AptoSOS ones and Co event recaps. It's good having a separate one for each edition.

I wondered though, when does a current recap become a historical recap?

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Mon Feb 28, 2011 6:17 pm
by Soph K
Ryan Taylor wrote:when does a current recap become a historical recap?
That's a good question...I have absolutely no idea whatsoever!

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Mon Feb 28, 2011 6:21 pm
by Soph K
You see, I think it would be neater and tidier; the topic would get really full, though. Maybe there should be a topic for 'recaps 1960 to 1970', 'recaps 1971 to 1980', etc etc...so that they're in different sections depending on the date of the recap? Also, I think the historical recaps should go in the 'Historical Recaps' part and current recaps should go in the 'Current Recaps' part.

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Mon Feb 28, 2011 6:23 pm
by Soph K
Joseph Krol wrote:
Soph K wrote:do you think there should be a topic for recaps? debate...
It would be a bit impractical having all recaps in a single topic, as it would take ages to find any one recap.
True...still not convinced tough...


Back me up everyone! (If you want a topic for recaps.)

Convince me everybody! (If you do not want a topic for recaps.)

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Mon Feb 28, 2011 7:42 pm
by Mike Brown
Soph K wrote:
Joseph Krol wrote:
Soph K wrote:do you think there should be a topic for recaps? debate...
It would be a bit impractical having all recaps in a single topic, as it would take ages to find any one recap.
True...still not convinced tough...


Back me up everyone! (If you want a topic for recaps.)

Convince me everybody! (If you do not want a topic for recaps.)
Sounds like we need a poll... :)

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Mon Feb 28, 2011 8:06 pm
by Gevin Chapwell
Soph K wrote:Convince me everybody! (If you do not want a topic for recaps.)[/b]
It's not like they get in the way of other topics, as they have their own subforum. It can be a bit of a pain when you're looking at recent posts and it's all recaps, but eventually there won't be new historical recaps all the time (as there's a finite number) so I don't really see any long-term advantage in having one topic. And it would be really awkward.

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 7:36 pm
by Soph K
Gavin Chipper wrote:I think it would be too annoying. I find it a bit awkward finding recaps in tournmaments where they are all lumped in together.
Maybe, yeah.

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 7:38 pm
by Soph K
Gavin Chipper wrote:eventually there won't be new historical recaps all the time (as there's a finite number) so I don't really see any long-term advantage in having one topic. And it would be really awkward.
Very good reason! I'm almost completely convinced now, methinks.

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 7:40 pm
by Soph K
Mike Brown wrote:Sounds like we need a poll... :)
There is a poll, isn't there? I put one on... :?

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 11:41 pm
by Mike Brown
Soph K wrote:
Mike Brown wrote:Sounds like we need a poll... :)
There is a poll, isn't there? I put one on... :?
Sorry, just senility setting in... have cast my vote for 'no'.

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 11:20 am
by Ian Fitzpatrick
Looks like you're outnumbered, Sophie!

Re: DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE A TOPIC FOR RECAPS?

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 7:56 pm
by Soph K
Mike Brown wrote:
Soph K wrote:
Mike Brown wrote:Sounds like we need a poll... :)
There is a poll, isn't there? I put one on... :?
Sorry, just senility setting in... have cast my vote for 'no'.
ok :)

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 7:57 pm
by Soph K
Ian Fitzpatrick wrote:Looks like you're outnumbered, Sophie!
lol :lol: :roll: :D

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 11:07 pm
by Mike Brown
Soph K wrote:
Ian Fitzpatrick wrote:Looks like you're outnumbered, Sophie!
lol :lol: :roll: :D
Careful, any more smileys and you'll turn into James Robinson!

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 11:32 pm
by James Robinson
Mike Brown wrote:
Soph K wrote:
Ian Fitzpatrick wrote:Looks like you're outnumbered, Sophie!
lol :lol: :roll: :D
Careful, any more smileys and you'll turn into James Robinson!
Are you saying that's a bad thing, Mike :?: :?: :?:

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2011 2:11 pm
by Mike Brown
James Robinson wrote:Are you saying that's a bad thing, Mike :?: :?: :?:
Not necessarily, but it might be a bit of a shock for Sophie! :)

Re: Do you think there should be one topic just for recaps?

Posted: Fri Mar 04, 2011 6:54 pm
by Soph K
Mike Brown wrote:
Soph K wrote:
Ian Fitzpatrick wrote:Looks like you're outnumbered, Sophie!
lol :lol: :roll: :D
Careful, any more smileys and you'll turn into James Robinson!
lol :lol:

p.s. stuck to one smiley this time, i definitely do not want to turn into james!