Conundrum Suggestion
Conundrum Suggestion
"Let's see if you're right..."
As soon as we hear this phrase, we already know they're right. To keep the tension going, how about having "Wrong!" or "Loser!" or "Raspilled!" printed on the other side of the conundrum thingy, and the dude behind the screen turns it whichever way is appropriate?
As soon as we hear this phrase, we already know they're right. To keep the tension going, how about having "Wrong!" or "Loser!" or "Raspilled!" printed on the other side of the conundrum thingy, and the dude behind the screen turns it whichever way is appropriate?
-
Ryan Taylor
- Postmaster General
- Posts: 3661
- Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:18 pm
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
I like this idea, and I think it was mentioned before somewhere. It just adds an extra bit of drama especially if its a crucial conundrum. For example the SLEEPSUIT conundrum, although then again, we wouldn't have got to hear Chris say "oh my God"!
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
You can if you touch him in just the right way.Ryan Taylor wrote:we wouldn't have got to hear Chris say "oh my God"!
- Michael Wallace
- Racoonteur
- Posts: 5458
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 5:01 am
- Location: London
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Agree that this would make things like SLEEPSUIT more interesting, but it would feel pretty silly someone makes a very obviously wrong guess (but I suppose they could just do it in a jokey way, then). The other thing is it penalises wrong answers more, since your opponent gets more thinking time. (Although you might think this is ok, just pointing it out.)
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Yeah, I'd thought of the time/advantage thing. It also occurrs though that probably there isn't much 'tension' necessarily in waiting for a reveal, because usually it should be obvious upon hearing "an" answer whether it's the correct one or not. Although I guess a lot of people do sit there hopefully waiting to hear if their (obviously wrong) answer is correct.Michael Wallace wrote:Agree that this would make things like SLEEPSUIT more interesting, but it would feel pretty silly someone makes a very obviously wrong guess (but I suppose they could just do it in a jokey way, then). The other thing is it penalises wrong answers more, since your opponent gets more thinking time. (Although you might think this is ok, just pointing it out.)
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
And how would you avoid the fact that to be able to get to the wrong!!! without going past either the right answer or the word conundrum again and still be able to get to the right answer without going past either the wrong!!! or the word conundrum is impossible, without going past either the wrong!!! or the right answer on the way to the scramble?Jon Corby wrote:Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
I think for a 4-sided thing to fit inside the frame, its faces would have to be smaller.
Last edited by Jon O on Wed May 19, 2010 2:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Michael Wallace
- Racoonteur
- Posts: 5458
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 5:01 am
- Location: London
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Aren't there two spinny things? One on top that says COUNTDOWN and has the scramble, and one underneath that has CONUNDRUM and the answer, so it could spin one way for WRONG!!!! and the other way for the actual answer?Jon Corby wrote:Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Wow. It's impressive how many Countdown conundrums I've seen revealed without working out that's what happens.
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
However, I think they only spin in one direction. I don't like this idea of tension being brought in. Too many drawbacks.
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Yes, you're absolutely right!Michael Wallace wrote:Aren't there two spinny things? One on top that says COUNTDOWN and has the scramble, and one underneath that has CONUNDRUM and the answer, so it could spin one way for WRONG!!!! and the other way for the actual answer?Jon Corby wrote:Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
I always find it funny how difficult I find it to visualise the simplest things, even when I've seen them hundreds of times before. (I always marvel at the vision of others, like when new developments spring up and all connect into the existing roads and shit like that, I just think "who the hell saw what was there before, and figured that this would all work out?" But that's probably for another thread.)
-
Gevin Chapwell
- Post-apocalypse
- Posts: 14711
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:37 pm
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
I think you're probably just not good at visualising spinning things. If I had to guess, I'd say you've never been very good at fruit machines. Just call me Derren.Jon Corby wrote:Yes, you're absolutely right!
I always find it funny how difficult I find it to visualise the simplest things, even when I've seen them hundreds of times before. (I always marvel at the vision of others, like when new developments spring up and all connect into the existing roads and shit like that, I just think "who the hell saw what was there before, and figured that this would all work out?" But that's probably for another thread.)
- Dmitry Goretsky
- Acolyte
- Posts: 156
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2010 1:45 pm
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
No, one side has "COUNTDOWN", other has "CONUNDRUM", and other on of of two has conundrum, on the other has the answerJon Corby wrote:Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
I'm a probability guru, so please PM or e-mail me if you need some help about probabilities.
Truly yours,
Dmitry Goretsky <0668964628@mail.ru>
Truly yours,
Dmitry Goretsky <0668964628@mail.ru>
- Dmitry Goretsky
- Acolyte
- Posts: 156
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2010 1:45 pm
Re: Conundrum Suggestion
Yes!Jon Corby wrote:Yes, you're absolutely right!Michael Wallace wrote:Aren't there two spinny things? One on top that says COUNTDOWN and has the scramble, and one underneath that has CONUNDRUM and the answer, so it could spin one way for WRONG!!!! and the other way for the actual answer?Jon Corby wrote:Also, the conundrum thing is probably three-sided isn't it? So one side says "CONUNDRUM", one has the scramble and the last the answer. My way would need four sides. Is there any reason a four sided thing can't rotate in that frame?
I always find it funny how difficult I find it to visualise the simplest things, even when I've seen them hundreds of times before. (I always marvel at the vision of others, like when new developments spring up and all connect into the existing roads and shit like that, I just think "who the hell saw what was there before, and figured that this would all work out?" But that's probably for another thread.)
I'm a probability guru, so please PM or e-mail me if you need some help about probabilities.
Truly yours,
Dmitry Goretsky <0668964628@mail.ru>
Truly yours,
Dmitry Goretsky <0668964628@mail.ru>