Page 1 of 1

Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sat Dec 05, 2009 3:03 pm
by Andy Wilson
Simple question. If you were in Innis' shoes and had victory over probably the finals' most feared contestant within your grasp, would you have been brave enough not to just take the easy road?

I certainly wouldn't. I salute you o brave one.

Re: Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sat Dec 05, 2009 3:09 pm
by Kirk Bevins
I'd have gone 1 large all the way. Yes, Innis practises with 2 large relentlessly but it was well known that 1 large is so much easier for a human to solve (in 30 seconds at least) and I think a few of us were really surprised when he went 2 large.

Re: Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sat Dec 05, 2009 10:22 pm
by Innis Carson
Kirk Bevins wrote: it was well known that 1 large is so much easier for a human to solve (in 30 seconds at least)

I've heard this quite a few times, but I don't personally feel that to be the case and the apterous Statland stats don't agree with it either (in my case at least). Success rates from the "top players" lists are:

2 large:

Innis - 81%
Chris - 79%

1 large:

Innis - 79%
Chris - 86%

What I needed in that round was for Chris not to beat me, and 2 large just seems the better option there. While that conventional wisdom about 1 large is well-intentioned and probably true for most people, I don't think it's a concrete rule for all humans.

Re: Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sun Dec 06, 2009 12:55 am
by Kirk Bevins
Interesting Innis. You actually didn't have to *beat* Chris, you only had to make sure you got the numbers game spot on, or, failing that, at least equal Chris.

If you feel confident that you'd max 2 large games more often than 1 large games then you did the right thing.

Re: Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:55 am
by Charlie Reams
Kirk Bevins wrote: If you feel confident that you'd max 2 large games more often than 1 large games then you did the right thing.
...which is exactly what the stats say.

Re: Would you have chosen anything other than 1 large

Posted: Sun Dec 06, 2009 2:37 am
by Kirk Bevins
Charlie Reams wrote:
Kirk Bevins wrote: If you feel confident that you'd max 2 large games more often than 1 large games then you did the right thing.
...which is exactly what the stats say.
Yeah but just because he has a higher percentage doesn't mean he has a higher confidence.