Page 1 of 1

What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 2:18 am
by Jason Larsen
I have just received word that another online game site that I go to has just been given a cease-and-desist order.

This worries me, because Apterous has not been taken down yet.

Granted, this other site is a favorite of mine, but I'm wondering how the unthinkable could happen to Apterous.

Let's say that Channel 4 gives Charlie a cease-and-desist order to take Apterous down. How can that be?

Charlie said, "At the risk of being sued by Channel 4, I will not use any music on the site.

Yet, he has used Phil Reynolds' outstanding piano piece as think music for each round.

I am trying to sound as rational as possible. When I speak of the Constitution, all of you would probably look at me like a deer in the headlights if I were in the UK. In plain English, the first amendment in the Constitution states freedom of speech. At the same time, "It's not what you say, it's how you say it." This is intended to be a debate and not an argument.

So, could someone please sort this out? Why is Apterous still around and what will happen if the unthinkable occurs?

One final word, I am placing this in the General forum in case Channel 4 tracks Internet hits.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 7:58 am
by Charlie Reams
About five back accounts, three ounces and two vehicles.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 8:20 am
by Matthew Green
But finally it could slightly teeter and end up as the reverse side of the title board. Horizon.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 1:18 pm
by Jason Larsen
Seriously, why hasn't Apterous been taken down?

This matter is up for debate and not intended to be an argument.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 1:21 pm
by Ian Fitzpatrick
Jason Larsen wrote:Seriously, why hasn't Apterous been taken down?

This matter is up for debate and not intended to be an argument.
Why should it be taken down? Or have I missed something?

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 1:36 pm
by Derek Hazell
Jason Larsen wrote:Seriously, why hasn't Apterous been taken down?

This matter is up for debate and not intended to be an argument.
Apterous doesn't encroach onto anyone else's territory. It has a different name, different music (as you said), and is the only decent online version of this type of words-and-numbers game. As you know, the producers of the television programme Countdown are aware of the site, and have never expressed any desire to start an online version of that show.
I remember an outcry when "Scrabulous" was removed by the makers of Scrabble, and that was because they wanted to start their own official Scrabble game for sites like Facebook. Maybe the site which you mention that was taken down also got in the way of a planned official Internet spin-off.
Far from competing with the TV show Countdown, the website Apterous, actually produces more interest in that show, and also several players who want to go on to compete in that show, so this seems a very different situation to me.
There you go Jason, there's you discussion.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 1:42 pm
by Sue Sanders
Derek Hazell wrote:
Jason Larsen wrote:Seriously, why hasn't Apterous been taken down?

This matter is up for debate and not intended to be an argument.
Apterous doesn't encroach onto anyone else's territory. It has a different name, different music (as you said), and is the only decent online version of this type of words-and-numbers game. As you know, the producers of the television programme Countdown are aware of the site, and have never expressed any desire to start an online version of that show.
I remember an outcry when "Scrabulous" was removed by the makers of Scrabble, and that was because they wanted to start their own official Scrabble game for sites like Facebook. Maybe the site which you mention that was taken down also got in the way of a planned official Internet spin-off.
Far from competing with the TV show Countdown, the website Apterous, actually produces more interest in that show, and also several players who want to go on to compete in that show, so this seems a very different situation to me.
There you Jason, there's your discussion.
Well Dez, you've written a sensible thread that should erase Jason's fears. Have you thought of writing for the Daily Mail??

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 1:55 pm
by Jason Larsen
Thank you, Derek!

I'm sorry for causing a stir, Ian.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 2:20 pm
by JackHurst
Derek Hazell wrote: Far from competing with the TV show Countdown, the website Apterous, actually produces more interest in that show, and also several players who want to go on to compete in that show, so this seems a very different situation to me.
There you go Jason, there's you discussion.
That bit. It gets mentioned on the show a lot too, (albeit not by name), and they seem to be allowing it to be promoted slightly, if anything.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 8:23 pm
by Jason Larsen
Apterous? Is that because they don't want the name of any big website mentioned and Rachel Riley stood there all stone-faced when it was a maximum in Dictionary Corner, Jack?

In other words, is it because of conflict of interest that they have to let it go?

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 9:18 pm
by JackHurst
Jason Larsen wrote:Apterous? Is that because they don't want the name of any big website mentioned and Rachel Riley stood there all stone-faced when it was a maximum in Dictionary Corner, Jack?

In other words, is it because of conflict of interest that they have to let it go?
I dont know the answer to that question, nor do I really know what you are tyying to ask, but ill reiterate my previous post:

There have been numerous references to "online play" on the show, but to my knowledge, apterous.org has never been mentioned as the website where you can play countdown online. This implies to me that the people on power dont mind about the apterous website, but if its actually mentioned by name they'd have to fill out paperwork or get permission from so and so which they cba to do. I know very little about this sort of thing, but in my limited imagination, thats what i thought. :D

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:28 pm
by Ian Fitzpatrick
When Kirk was on he said he deliberately didn't mention the site by name because he didn't want all his pupils logging on to pester him and others.

I still can't fathom out what Jason is on about!

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:46 pm
by David Williams
I don't have any real legal knowledge, but I would have thought that the owners of Countdown would have a pretty strong case for shutting down apterous. It's a blatant copy of the game, and any "disclaimers" only reinforce that. How would someone get on if they put out a board game called apterous, with a statement on the box that it had absolutely no resemblance to Countdown? And claiming that it was being sold at a loss wouldn't cut much ice.

But there's a legal principle called estoppel. Once you've approved or condoned something you lose the right to assert the opposite position, so C4 would have a problem. But Armand Jannot? I imagine it depends what rights he's ceded to C4.

No lawyers out there?

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 11:02 pm
by Jason Larsen
Jack, I was asking if anyone plugged Apterous on the show.

Ian, now that I think about it, it wouldn't be a problem!

And David, Armand Jammot has passed away.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 11:40 pm
by Kirk Bevins
Charlie plugged c4countdown but not apterous. I think it would be OK to say apterous by name on the show but the few of us who have mentioned it have kept it to "online study" (possibly to stop future opponents beating them?)

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 1:21 am
by Jason Larsen
I see, Kirk.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 11:07 am
by Charlie Reams
David Williams wrote:It's a blatant copy of the game, and any "disclaimers" only reinforce that.
I'm not infringing their trademark, they do not have a patent and copyright does not apply to the rules of games.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 11:34 am
by Ian Fitzpatrick
Charlie Reams wrote:
David Williams wrote:It's a blatant copy of the game, and any "disclaimers" only reinforce that.
I'm not infringing their trademark, they do not have a patent and copyright does not apply to the rules of games.
It can't be a blatant copy of the game otherwise everyone would be on television.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 11:38 am
by Charlie Reams
Ian Fitzpatrick wrote:It can't be a blatant copy of the game otherwise everyone would be on television.
Maybe Kirk knows something you don't...

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 12:16 pm
by David Williams
Charlie Reams wrote:
David Williams wrote:It's a blatant copy of the game, and any "disclaimers" only reinforce that.
I'm not infringing their trademark, they do not have a patent and copyright does not apply to the rules of games.
If that's the legal position I'm delighted, if a little surprised. Not least because what you say doesn't actually contradict what I said.

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 12:39 pm
by Charlie Reams
David Williams wrote:If that's the legal position I'm delighted, if a little surprised. Not least because what you say doesn't actually contradict what I said.
Maybe I should've quoted this bit instead:
I would have thought that the owners of Countdown would have a pretty strong case for shutting down apterous

Re: What is the difference?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 1:14 pm
by Jason Larsen
Thank you, Charlie!