Page 1 of 1

Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Mar 06, 2009 3:11 pm
by Charlie Reams
http://blogs.channel4.com/thetvshow/200 ... countdown/

Helen Warner (Channel 4's Head of Daytime) seems almost as impressed with the new team as I am.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Mar 06, 2009 4:48 pm
by David Williams
This would be the same Helen Warner who forced Carol out, then? So we think this was a good thing now, do we?

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Mar 06, 2009 5:09 pm
by Charlie Reams
David Williams wrote:This would be the same Helen Warner who forced Carol out, then? So we think this was a good thing now, do we?
Yes.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Mar 06, 2009 5:31 pm
by Dinos Sfyris
The Writer: Some viewers still miss Des’s showbiz stories

I certainly miss his yodelling joke :roll:

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Mar 07, 2009 4:00 pm
by Chris Philpot
"The TV Show", the programme that ties into the blog linked to in this thread, is about to start on Channel 4 if anyone is interested.

Personally, I miss a little of the interactivity between viewers and host that there used to be - the jokes, the anecdotes. That said, the new format is certainly enjoyable enough.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Tue Mar 10, 2009 9:12 pm
by Lesley Jeavons
Loved it before, love it still! Love everyone! :D

The main difference I find between Carol and Rachel's screen time (aside from putting up the letters, numbers and solving) is that often when Carol said something it was off the cuff, but Rachel has only had the opportunity to answer or react to what Jeff puts to her, rather than initiate anything herself. But I'm sure more spur of the moment chat will come.

Also Jeff mentioned The Everly Brothers the other day, so he gets full marks for that in my book! :D

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 10:05 pm
by Derek Hazell
Does anyone miss the way Deso used to focus so much on the game by doing such things as working out the points and letting the viewer know as soon as someone had got the victory? Or do people prefer to work it out for themselves, or just wait for the end and be surprised, seeing as Jeff never mentions such things?

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 10:17 pm
by Ben Hunter
Derek Hazell wrote:Does anyone miss the way Deso used to focus so much on the game by doing such things as working out the points and letting the viewer know as soon as someone had got the victory? Or do people prefer to work it out for themselves, or just wait for the end and be surprised, seeing as Jeff never mentions such things?
Er, he does mention such things.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 10:30 pm
by Derek Hazell
Ben Hunter wrote:
Derek Hazell wrote:Does anyone miss the way Deso used to focus so much on the game by doing such things as working out the points and letting the viewer know as soon as someone had got the victory? Or do people prefer to work it out for themselves, or just wait for the end and be surprised, seeing as Jeff never mentions such things?
Er, he does mention such things.
Well I have watched every Jeff Stelling episode, and I have never heard him do so. Amazingly my brain must shut off at that exact moment each episode.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 10:31 pm
by Charlie Reams
Derek Hazell wrote: Well I have watched every Jeff Stelling episode, and I have never heard him do so. Amazingly my brain must shut off at that exact moment each episode.
Yep, definitely no way you could just forget something.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 10:51 pm
by Phil Reynolds
Derek Hazell wrote:Does anyone miss the way Deso used to focus so much on the game by doing such things as working out the points and letting the viewer know as soon as someone had got the victory? Or do people prefer to work it out for themselves, or just wait for the end and be surprised, seeing as Jeff never mentions such things?
Jeff mentions the scores from time to time during the game, which is presumably to keep visually impaired viewers (who can't read the digital score displays in front of the contestants) reminded of who's in front and by how much. I never understood why Des O felt it necessary to read out the scores after every round.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 11:08 pm
by Brian Moore
Charlie Reams wrote:
Derek Hazell wrote: Well I have watched every Jeff Stelling episode, and I have never heard him do so. Amazingly my brain must shut off at that exact moment each episode.
Yep, definitely no way you could just forget something.
Isn't Derek referring to the way DesO used to say things like "well, you're just playing for pride now" once one person's score was unassailable? Jeff does do plenty of "well there's a long way to go yet, things can change very quickly", when there's a wide margin, but I'm not aware that he admits when the game's effectively over.

Not that I care one jot about this really - Jeff's doing a very fine job (as is the whole team) ... even my mother has taken to him after initial concerns.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2009 11:19 pm
by Derek Hazell
Phil Reynolds wrote:Jeff mentions the scores from time to time during the game, which is presumably to keep visually impaired viewers (who can't read the digital score displays in front of the contestants) reminded of who's in front and by how much. I never understood why Des O felt it necessary to read out the scores after every round.
I know that the score has been mentioned regularly by both men, and I also assumed this was for the visually impaired. This can only be a good thing, and none of us know whether we might have sight problems in the future.
Brian Moore wrote:Isn't Derek referring to the way DesO used to say things like "well, you're just playing for pride now" once one person's score was unassailable?
Yes thank you Brian, that is exactly what I was talking about. I know my post was clumsily written, but I had trouble explaining it. I was just talking about how DesO always told who the winner was as soon as he worked it out.

It's not a big issue, I was just curious that was all.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 1:36 am
by Ben Hunter
Derek Hazell wrote:
Brian Moore wrote:Isn't Derek referring to the way DesO used to say things like "well, you're just playing for pride now" once one person's score was unassailable?
Yes thank you Brian, that is exactly what I was talking about. I know my post was clumsily written, but I had trouble explaining it. I was just talking about how DesO always told who the winner was as soon as he worked it out.
Des would often say things that suggested he believed a player had a chance to win when they were more than 20 points behind with only the numbers and conundrum to go. I'm sure this has been mentioned a few times on this forum, and it's definitely something that annoyed me about Des (though I liked his general manner).

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 2:41 pm
by Derek Hazell
Helen Warner is on Channel 4 now, on "The TV Show" defending her decision to get rid of Carol Vorderman. She has just had an argument with journalist Carole Malone about it, and members of the audience are now giving their views. As usual Krishnan is doing a very good job of not taking sides with his employer and asking the tough questions.

I hope some of you will have the chance to catch it on 4+1

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 3:13 pm
by Charlie Reams
Derek Hazell wrote:Helen Warner is on Channel 4 now, on "The TV Show" defending her decision to get rid of Carol Vorderman. She has just had an argument with journalist Carole Malone about it, and members of the audience are now giving their views. As usual Krishnan is doing a very good job of not taking sides with his employer and asking the tough questions.

I hope some of you will have the chance to catch it on 4+1
Jono was invited to be in the audience, I wonder if he went?

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 3:41 pm
by Derek Hazell
Charlie Reams wrote:Jono was invited to be in the audience, I wonder if he went?
I didn't see him (judging by his avatar picture), although you yourself made an appearance.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 5:02 pm
by Rosemary Roberts
Derek Hazell wrote:As usual Krishnan is doing a very good job of not taking sides with his employer and asking the tough questions.
My impression was that he was doing a very good job of not letting anybody finish what they wanted to say unless they had no idea what they were talking about. The prat whose only complaint was Rachel's pronounciation had plenty of time for his "point", but did Helen Warner get to finish a single sentence?

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 5:17 pm
by Derek Hazell
Rosemary Roberts wrote:
Derek Hazell wrote:As usual Krishnan is doing a very good job of not taking sides with his employer and asking the tough questions.
My impression was that he was doing a very good job of not letting anybody finish what they wanted to say unless they had no idea what they were talking about. The prat whose only complaint was Rachel's pronounciation had plenty of time for his "point", but did Helen Warner get to finish a single sentence?
Yes Rosemary, I suppose you're right about him interrupting too much. I must have been too busy admiring his impartiality (that's the word!) to be impartial myself.

As for that prat, he was a day too late, and obviously didn't watch the show yesterday! Makes him a double-prat (a c@&*?) by my reckoning.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 5:58 pm
by Rosemary Roberts
Derek Hazell wrote:Yes Rosemary, I suppose you're right about him interrupting too much. I must have been too busy admiring his impartiality (that's the word!) to be impartial myself.
Surely we were not expected to believe this TV Show was live? I got a distinct impression of the attitude Phil encountered on Weakest Link: "you needn't bother to argue, because if you do win a point we will edit it out". To be fair, that is probably not a technique that Helen Warner is entirely unfamiliar with.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Apr 04, 2009 7:09 pm
by Derek Hazell
Rosemary Roberts wrote:
Derek Hazell wrote:Yes Rosemary, I suppose you're right about him interrupting too much. I must have been too busy admiring his impartiality (that's the word!) to be impartial myself.
Surely we were not expected to believe this TV Show was live? I got a distinct impression of the attitude Phil encountered on Weakest Link: "you needn't bother to argue, because if you do win a point we will edit it out". To be fair, that is probably not a technique that Helen Warner is entirely unfamiliar with.
They have been claiming "The TV Show" is live ever since the beginning . . . maybe if Jono (or any other forum members) did go, they can enlighten us.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 3:26 pm
by Phil Reynolds
Derek Hazell wrote:Helen Warner is on Channel 4 now, on "The TV Show" defending her decision to get rid of Carol Vorderman. She has just had an argument with journalist Carole Malone about it, and members of the audience are now giving their views.
Just watched this on Catch-Up. Jono didn't appear to be in the audience, although we were treated to some criticism of Rachel's pronunciation by Countdown fan "Barry", who amusingly undermined his point somewhat by being unable to pronounce the word "pronunciation".

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 7:21 pm
by D Eadie
What pronunciation........she doesn't do it anymore.

Bear in mind we record 3 weeks worth of shows in 3 days, so if there is something viewers don't always like, it can take up to 6 weeks on screen sometimes before we can rectify it.

We're 3 months in to a brand new team and i think they both are doing fantastically well.

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Mon Apr 06, 2009 7:28 pm
by Derek Hazell
D Eadie wrote:What pronunciation........she doesn't do it anymore.
Hence my comment above
Derek Hazell wrote:As for that prat, he was a day too late, and obviously didn't watch the show yesterday! Makes him a double-prat (a c@&*?) by my reckoning.
and my other one here http://www.c4countdown.co.uk/viewtopic. ... 481#p39481 . . .

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Wed Apr 08, 2009 7:17 pm
by Derek Hazell
I wish "eachofyou" was a word. It's one of my favourite things Jeff says, and it would be a very useful 9.

If we can have "insofar" and "inasmuch" I think we should start compacting more of these into words!

Re: Feedback on the new Countdown

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2009 4:17 pm
by Derek Hazell
Derek Hazell wrote:Helen Warner is on Channel 4 now, on "The TV Show" defending her decision to get rid of Carol Vorderman. She has just had an argument with journalist Carole Malone about it, and members of the audience are now giving their views. As usual Krishnan is doing a very good job of not taking sides with his employer and asking the tough questions.

I hope some of you will have the chance to catch it on 4+1
Countdown got a mention on "The TV Show" again this month. Sadly, a very tabloid-like and stereotypical mention from a supposed serious news journalist though: "On the subject of daring outfits, Channel 4's greying Countdown audience got steamed up by Rachel Riley, and her line in racy minidresses".

Maybe we should bombard the message boards with our comments, seeing as the main Countdown forum has fans with an age range of 11 to 83, and a very small percentage of our talk is about Rachel's clothing. Or actually, it's probably not worth it.

Incidently the episode from April about Carol Vorderman is strangely still available on the site, for anyone who missed it: http://www.channel4.com/programmes/the-tv-show/4od